I was on the Crabtree & Evelyn website last earlier this week to pick up some home perfume on clearance. I noticed that they carry two different lines that are mostly Paraben Free.
Their Naturals Line is comparable in price and product size to Bath & Body Works.
Naturals Pineapple & Ginger Body Lotion
8.5 fl. oz. - $10 - Sale
Their Aromatherapy Distillation Collection is a bit fancier - and a bit pricier, but still mostly Paraben Free. Remember to always check the ingredients list!
Aromatherapy Conditioning Body Lotion
8.5 fl. oz - $15.60 - Sale